Spain vs Portugal for a US Move: The Honest Trade-offs

Lisbon or Madrid? Lisbon or Barcelona? If you're an American planning a move to the Iberian peninsula, this is usually the question, and the internet answers it with sunshine and food. The things that actually decide it are duller: which visa fits your income, how each country taxes you, and how long it takes to earn a second passport. Here's the honest comparison, written from Lisbon but fair to both sides.
Two quick notes first. Visa thresholds and tax rules move, so read every figure here as the position at current rates and check the official source before you apply. And this is a decision guide, not legal or tax advice. For anything with money or a passport riding on it, talk to a lawyer or a cross-border tax adviser who works with Americans.
The short version
- Living on passive income? Portugal's D7 asks for about €920 a month. Spain's non-lucrative visa asks for about €2,400 a month.
- Working remotely? Spain's digital nomad visa has the lower bar, roughly €2,850 a month. Portugal's D8 asks for €3,680.
- Tax breaks are narrow in both. Portugal closed NHR to newcomers. Spain's Beckham regime suits people moving for a job, including remote employees.
- A second passport takes 10 years in both for a US national. Portugal lets you keep your US citizenship without a renunciation step. Spain asks you to declare one.
- Lisbon is an hour behind Madrid and Barcelona, which helps if you work US hours.
Spain vs Portugal at a glance
| What matters | Portugal (Lisbon) | Spain (Madrid, Barcelona) |
|---|---|---|
| Passive-income visa | D7: about €920 a month, at current rates. | Non-lucrative visa: about €2,400 a month, at current rates. |
| Remote-work visa | D8: €3,680 a month, at current rates. | Digital nomad visa: roughly €2,850 a month, at current rates. |
| Special tax regime | IFICI, for listed research, startup and highly skilled roles. | Beckham regime, for people moving for work. |
| Wealth tax | No tax on overall net worth. | Regional wealth tax, plus a national tax on fortunes above €3 million. |
| Citizenship for a US national | 10 years of legal residence. | 10 years of legal, continuous residence. |
| Keep your US passport | No renunciation required. | Renunciation declaration required. |
Visas when you don't need a local employer
Most Americans weighing these two countries aren't moving for a local job. They're retiring, living on savings or investments, or bringing a remote job with them. Both countries have a visa for each case, and the income rules are where they differ most.
Living on passive income: Portugal's D7 vs Spain's non-lucrative visa
Portugal ties its money rule to the national minimum wage, which is €920 a month at current rates. The main applicant needs 100% of it, a second adult needs another 50%, and each child needs another 30%. You show the means for at least a year, which in practice often means savings held in a Portuguese bank account. Our D7 visa guide walks through the documents.
Spain ties its rule to the IPREM, a public income index used for benefits and thresholds. You need 400% of it, about €2,400 a month or €28,800 a year at current rates. Each family member adds 100%, about €600 a month. You show it for the whole length of the permit. Our non-lucrative visa guide covers the details.
So a single retiree needs roughly two and a half times as much monthly income for Spain as for Portugal. That gap alone settles the decision for a lot of people.
Neither visa is meant for working. Spain's consulate in New York says plainly that the non-lucrative visa doesn't allow teleworking. Spain also expects you to actually live there: to renew, you must have spent more than 183 days in Spain in the calendar year.
Who this favours: Portugal, clearly, if your passive income is modest. If you comfortably clear Spain's bar, the visa stops being the deciding factor.
Working remotely: Portugal's D8 vs Spain's digital nomad visa
Portugal's D8 asks for average monthly income of at least four times the minimum wage over the last three months. At current rates that's €3,680 a month. You'll also need your employment contract, or your contracts with clients if you freelance.
Spain's digital nomad visa asks for 200% of the Spanish minimum wage. That works out to about €34,200 a year at current rates, or roughly €2,850 a month spread over twelve. The first family member adds 75% of the minimum wage, and each one after that adds 25%.
Spain has extra conditions. You need a degree or at least three years of professional experience. Your employer or clients must have been active for at least a year, and you must have worked with them for at least the last three months. Freelancers can take Spanish clients, but they can't make up more than 20% of the work. Our Spain digital nomad visa guide has the full list.
Who this favours: Spain, if your remote income sits between the two bars. Above €3,680 a month, both are open to you and the other sections matter more.
One more thing on investors: Spain closed its golden visa route for property and investment. Portugal still has one, though property no longer counts. Our guide on whether the Portugal golden visa is still worth it covers what's left.
Tax: both countries tax you, and so does the US
Start with the part that doesn't change. The US taxes its citizens on worldwide income wherever they live, so you'll keep filing a US return. You also keep reporting foreign bank accounts to the Treasury above the threshold. Our guide to moving to Portugal from the US and our guide to moving to Spain from the US cover the US side.
Both countries tax their residents on worldwide income too. You become tax resident in Spain after more than 183 days in a calendar year. In Portugal it's more than 183 days in any twelve-month period, or keeping a home here that looks like your habitual residence. Both have an income tax treaty with the US. The IRS also says foreign tax credits and the foreign earned income exclusion need a US return to claim.
Portugal: NHR is gone, IFICI is narrow
Portugal's old non-habitual resident regime, NHR, is closed to new applicants. Its replacement, IFICI, gives a flat 20% rate on qualifying work income for ten years. It's limited to listed activities, such as research, certified startups and some highly qualified roles. You also mustn't have been tax resident in Portugal in the previous five years.
For most D7 retirees and many D8 remote workers, IFICI won't apply, so you're on ordinary Portuguese rates. That's not a disaster, just not the bargain older articles promise.
Spain: the Beckham regime, and a wealth tax
Spain's Beckham regime is for people who move to Spain for work. That includes employees who arrive on the digital nomad visa. You pay a flat 24% on work income up to €600,000 a year, and 47% above that. Broadly, most income from outside Spain other than your work income stays out of Spanish income tax while it lasts.
It runs for the year you move and the five years after. You can't have been tax resident in Spain in the previous five years. Retirees and non-lucrative visa holders don't qualify, because there's no work move. Our Beckham law guide explains who it suits.
Spain also has an annual wealth tax, which each region sets and can reduce. On top of it sits a national solidarity tax on net wealth above €3 million, and it collects what a regional discount leaves untaxed.
Portugal doesn't tax your overall net worth each year. Its nearest equivalent is an extra yearly tax on residential property, the adicional ao IMI. It only bites once your residential property's taxable value passes €600,000 per person.
One more thing for Americans who'll work: the US has social security agreements with both countries. They're designed to stop you paying into two systems for the same work. Ask your adviser which one you should be covered by.
Who this favours: Spain, for a well-paid remote employee who qualifies for Beckham. Portugal, for anyone with large assets, since Spain's wealth taxes can apply. For a typical retiree, it's close to a draw, so model your own numbers.
Citizenship and keeping your US passport
For many Americans this is the deciding factor. An EU passport means you can live and work anywhere in the EU, and it outlasts any visa rule change. Both countries now ask a US national for ten years.
Portugal: longer than it was, and dual nationality is fine
Portugal changed its nationality law, and the new rules are in force. A US national now needs at least 10 years of legal residence before applying to naturalise. Citizens of Portuguese-speaking countries and EU citizens need 7. It used to be five years for everyone, which is still what plenty of older articles say.
Two details matter. Time spent waiting for your first residence permit no longer counts towards the ten years. And applications already pending when the law changed are judged under the old rules.
You'll also need to pass a test of Portuguese language and culture, history and national symbols. You'll need to show you know the basic rights and duties of a citizen, and that you can support yourself. Some of the practical detail depends on regulations, so check the current procedure with the IRN, the registry that handles nationality, before you plan around a date.
The good news: Portugal doesn't ask you to give up your US citizenship. Under Portuguese law, a dual national is simply treated as Portuguese in Portugal.
Spain: ten years, two exams and a renunciation
Spain's civil code asks for ten years of legal, continuous residence immediately before you apply. The short two-year route is for nationals of Latin American countries, Andorra, the Philippines, Equatorial Guinea and Portugal, plus people of Sephardic origin. The US isn't on that list. If you've been married to a Spaniard for a year, one year of residence is enough.
You'll also sit two exams run by the Instituto Cervantes: a Spanish language exam at A2 level (the DELE) and a test of Spanish civics and culture (the CCSE).
Then the hard part. Spain asks most new citizens to declare that they renounce their previous nationality, and Americans aren't exempt. The US State Department's position is that naturalising abroad doesn't by itself cost you US citizenship, because losing it requires intent. That's reassuring, but it's exactly the kind of thing to check with a lawyer before you swear the oath.
Who this favours: Portugal, even after the change. Same ten years, no renunciation step.
Healthcare
In Portugal, the consulate asks for insurance that covers your medical expenses, including urgent care and repatriation, for the visa stage. Once you hold a residence permit, you can register at your local health centre, get your número de utente (patient number) and use the SNS, the public health service. The catch is waiting times, especially for a family doctor in Lisbon. Our guide to the SNS and private cover explains how most residents combine the two.
Spain is stricter for passive-income residents. The non-lucrative visa needs private health insurance from an insurer authorised in Spain, covering everything the public system covers. The New York consulate adds no co-payments and no deductible. You keep it for as long as you hold the permit. The digital nomad visa accepts private insurance, or public cover if you pay into Spanish social security.
Looking for immigration lawyers in Lisbon?
English-speaking, screened and ranked by real reviews from the expat community.
Who this favours: Portugal, if you want access to the public system on a passive-income visa. Spain is no harder if you'd buy a private policy anyway.
Paperwork and waiting times
Neither country is quick, and you should plan for that in both. Portugal's immigration agency, AIMA, inherited a huge backlog. The government's own recovery team said about a million files were pending when it started, around 450,000 of them one older type of application. It reported clearing almost all of those before it closed, but appointment waits are still a common complaint.
In Spain, the friction is often getting appointments, especially the cita previa for your fingerprints and TIE residence card. In Madrid and Barcelona, finding a free slot can take real persistence. On the consulate side, Spain's New York consulate gives itself up to three months to decide a non-lucrative visa.
In both countries, paperwork in a language you don't read yet is where most people get stuck. That's the point at which an English-speaking lawyer earns their fee.
Who this favours: neither, honestly. Budget time and patience for both, and keep copies of everything.
Cost of living and housing
Rent is the number that decides your budget in all three cities. In Lisbon, the median rent on a new lease is roughly €17 per square metre a month. That puts a comfortable 60 square metre one-bedroom at around €1,030 a month, as a current ballpark. Our Lisbon cost of living guide has the full budget.
In Barcelona, a one-bedroom in a well-connected mid-range area usually runs about €950 to €1,300 a month, as a current ballpark. Further out it's roughly €700 to €1,000, and the centre runs €1,200 to €1,900 or more. Our Barcelona monthly cost guide breaks it down. We haven't published a Madrid cost guide yet, so we won't guess at a figure.
Local pay is lower in Portugal. The minimum wage is €920 a month there and €1,221 a month in Spain, before deductions. That matters if you'll earn locally. If your income comes from the US, it matters far less than the rent on the flat you choose.
Who this favours: it depends on the neighbourhood more than the country. Compare the same size of flat in the areas you'd actually live in.
Language and daily life
If you learned some Spanish at school, you'll have a head start in Spain, and you'll need it for the citizenship exam. European Portuguese takes time to tune into, and it sounds quite different from Brazilian Portuguese, so check which one a course teaches. Portugal's citizenship test is in Portuguese, so plan to learn it properly if a passport is the goal.
A practical point for remote workers: mainland Portugal is an hour behind Spain all year. Overlapping with a US East Coast team is a little easier from Lisbon.
Beyond the paperwork, the best way to choose is still a long visit to each. Spend a few weeks in the neighbourhood you'd live in, outside peak season.
A quick way to decide
- Lean towards Portugal if you live on a modest pension or investment income, want public healthcare on a passive-income visa, or want a second passport without a renunciation step.
- Lean towards Spain if you work remotely on a salary between the two income bars, qualify for the Beckham regime, or already speak good Spanish.
- Either works if you earn well above both bars. Then it comes down to the city, the neighbourhood and where you'd rather spend ten years.
Get help from an English-speaking pro in Lisbon
The visa file is where small mistakes cost months. Compare English-speaking immigration lawyers in Lisbon for the D7, the D8 or a residence permit. If you'd rather have someone handle the whole move, look at relocation companies in Lisbon. For IFICI or your first Portuguese tax return, try English-speaking tax consultants in Lisbon.
Leaning towards Spain? We also list immigration lawyers in Madrid and immigration lawyers in Barcelona.
Every business on Locallista is screened before it's listed, and every review is phone-verified. The ranking reflects real expat experience, not who paid the most, and contacting them is free.
Frequently asked questions
Is it easier for an American to move to Portugal or to Spain?
Which is better for retirees from the US?
Can I keep my US citizenship if I become Portuguese or Spanish?
How long does it take an American to get Portuguese citizenship now?
Can I work remotely for a US employer on a passive-income visa?
Will I pay tax in both the US and Portugal or Spain?
Is Lisbon cheaper than Madrid or Barcelona?
Join Locallista. Recommend Locallista.
Locallista is powered by your feedback. Your reviews, suggestions and ideas help everyone grow - fellow expats thrive and great local providers get the recognition they deserve.


